| Lost password
481 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
newbie needs opinion
 1
 1
07/20/2005 23:44
newbie 
07/20/2005 23:44
newbie 
newbie needs opinion

I have a dilema and need some opinions. I'd appreciate any advice. Let me explain a few things first. I have emailed pictures of my hand to Dr. Pess and after looking at them he responded by saying that although the type of DC I have is one of the more difficult to do NA treatment on, he felt NA would give me considerable relief. Not straightening it completely out mind you, but make it considerably better than what it is.

Since I'm self-employeed and self-pay, insurance is not an issue. Of the doctors that perform NA treatment, the 2 that are closest to me are Dr. Pess of Eatontown, NJ and Dr. Spacek of Montreal, Canada.

Dr. Pess office informed me the procedure would be $700.00

My understanding is Dr. Spacek cost is a $100.00 office cost and $155.00 per finger. I just have DC on my left pinky finger. So the cost I assume would be $255.00.

As you can see that is a $445.00 difference. Here's my dilema.

1)
I've not really heard much about Dr. Spacek. So I'm a little worried about the "you get what you pay for" thing.
Of all the doctors I've checked, most are in Dr. Pess's range of $700-$800. Dr. Spacek is only $255, but she's in Canada and maybe that accounts for the lower cost.

2)
I've heard that some Canadian doctors won't even treat US citizens. I know they probably would not accept US medical insurance, but not treat? Has anybody heard of this.

**** So;
(IF) Dr. Spacek would treat me and (IF) the price is $255.00 would you go ahead and go to Dr. Spacek in Canada and save the $445.00 -OR- would you not take the chance and just go to Dr. Pess and pay the $700.00.

Of course my health is worth more than $455.00, but that is a lot of money to me and if Dr. Spacek is qualified? In case your wondering, I'd be driving and the difference is 7 1/2 hrs to Dr. Pess and 8 1/2 to Dr. Spacek.

Any advice? does anybody know about Dr. Spacek or if Canadian doctors accept US patients? I tried to call her, but it was a Fax number. I think I have her real number 514-340-2770.




07/21/2005 23:59
Tommy

not registered

07/21/2005 23:59
Tommy

not registered

office visit

Newbie, make sure that you factor in the cost office visit. That's seperate from the procedure.

07/21/2005 23:12
Steve Abrams

not registered

07/21/2005 23:12
Steve Abrams

not registered

experience

At this level of financial difference, the basis of your decision should be the qualifications and experience of the doctors, not the dollar amount. As Dr. Eaton was my doctor, I do not have information on these two physicians, but with some digging you shold be able to make an informed decision.

Steve

07/21/2005 23:54
jimh 
07/21/2005 23:54
jimh 
experience

As far as I've been able to find out, Canadian doctors won't treat U.S. patients.

07/21/2005 23:27
Tommy

not registered

07/21/2005 23:27
Tommy

not registered

experience

Steve is absolutely right. That's why I flew across the country in February to go with the doctor who had already done 800 NA procedures. I could have had NA done in California and I may choose to in the future, but at that point in time I'm glad I went with the most experienced doctor.

07/22/2005 23:29
marjorie 
07/22/2005 23:29
marjorie 
nodule

Hi Newbie. You don't say where you live but travelling for so many hours to have the procedure means that you will have to pay for at least two nights accomodation. Seven hours travel will cost a lot in petrol (gas). You may find it difficult to drive for a couple of days after the procedure, I did but then we mainly drive manual cars. I live in England and go to Paris for my treatment. I cannot believe how much they charge in the USA. In Paris it would be less than $100. Look at the topic on this forum named 'a success story on the West Coast' Perhaps you could email that person and get some info. Seems to me that if you are going to spend a lot of money you may as well have a short holiday in Europe

07/23/2005 23:42
Frances

not registered

07/23/2005 23:42
Frances

not registered

nodule

Harry,

There is info about Dr. Spacek and her fees in this thread. I have been away for a while so I didn't spot it.

Frances

07/23/2005 23:57
Marjorie

not registered

07/23/2005 23:57
Marjorie

not registered

nodule

Your last sentence is bang on sister!....the prices sure are high in the US and it does equal the amount it costs to go to Europe when everything is factored in.

But...I saw a show that listed NJ and California amoungst the most expensive places to live in the US - that's why the price per finger is so much higher in those two locations. Personally I don't mind biting the bullet for now because these doctors have gone out on a limb for us ....after all....once there are doctors on every corner like we want .....the price will come down anyways won't it? Such is the way with supply and demand ;-)

Frances

07/23/2005 23:57
Frances

not registered

07/23/2005 23:57
Frances

not registered

nodule

Ooops..... that last post by 'Marjorie' was by me and meant for Marjorie. Sorry about that.

07/24/2005 23:26
marjorie 
07/24/2005 23:26
marjorie 
nodule

Hi Frances,
We do not have any doctors in the UK who do the needle procedure. How lucky we are that France is so close to us. If you need the needle procedure it is better to get it done as soon as possible. I cannot believe that some hand surgeons will not accept, that a procedure which has been practised for 30 years, is preferable to very invasive surgery.

 1
 1
straightening   absolutely   understanding   procedure   treatment   physicians   514-340-2770   California   accomodation   Canadian   considerable   experience   experienced   difference   doctors   procedures   self-employeed   information   qualifications   considerably