| Lost password
234 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
The Site is a Scam
 1 2 3 4 5 6
 1 2 3 4 5 6
02/20/2005 23:18
No Name

not registered

02/20/2005 23:18
No Name

not registered

Better Resources

This message string was intended to point out that this message board has been hijacked by individuals or individual to promote one option for treating DC and anyone new should be aware of anything posted here. From what I can see, most of the postings look to be false and anyone doing that should stop it.

That said: I advise any newcomers to search the National Institutes of Health website at: www.nih.gov. While surgery is claimed to be the best option at this point, there is a lot of good information there about dups, including clinical trials, papers and alternative treatment options.

Let's use this site to post information ONLY and links to that information. I hope this site can go in that direction. That will be a great improvement. Let's share facts and science.




02/20/2005 23:09
toM

not registered

02/20/2005 23:09
toM

not registered

No Name and Hypocrisy

You want science, which I presume you mean to be verifiable documented facts backed up by research and analysis, yet present no documentation (which I'm sure you do not have) to back up your contention that this board has been hijacked by a group of individuals or a single individual.

You also do not provide, even at a minimum, any proof that any postings here are false.

This is what is known as rank hypocrisy. Perhaps you should leave this board and enter politics.

02/20/2005 23:11
No Name

not registered

02/20/2005 23:11
No Name

not registered

False Postings

Randy & Tom,

I have had my login name hijacked a number of times on this site with messages I have not written sometimes within hours and I don't think its a coincidence. Reading some of these messages throughout this site this has been a complaint before and that is not in doubt.

As for science and facts. THAT is exactly what I'm proposing the site be used for regardless of the topic. I found the NIH site and encouraged others to explore it and not only is there is no harm in that, it is a proper use of a public forum.

i.e., here is what I learned and maybe it is of interest to others.

In fact, that is a better use of this site than to post misleading and highly suspect message about how stupid surgeons are and if they would only tell the world about NA everyone's worries would be over. My surgeon, family doctor and PT all know about NA and dicussed it with me.

So, Randy, to contest one of your points: where are the facts that surgeons are ignorant of NA and that they don't or refuse to tell patients about NA? Since you cannot back up that claim, the debate is over - you know your claim that surgeons are poorly inforemd about a long established procedure is silly and just wrong.

If either of you can prove that hand surgeons are unaware of a technique introduced by the French years ago, then you can claim to be right. But, since you cannot this outrageous statement, go back under your bridges. You are clearly angry men with axes to grind and that's a shame.

But, among the information on the NIH website are items about NA. Its neither good or bad. Its just there. Straightforward and allows the reader to intrepret it for themselves. Finding and sharing information like this will allow all of us who suffer from DC to be better informed consumers of health care.

When you come back wanting to attack me (and you will), try instead to offer information that is not bais and is informative regardless of the topic. I personnally do not know which techniques are best and do not claim to know. Unless there is an MD or PhD in your credidentials, how you claim to experts. Do not push your opinions on people, share information.

Are either of you up to that challenge? Can you share information without adding the politics?

02/20/2005 23:44
toM

not registered

02/20/2005 23:44
toM

not registered

No Facts Again

For such a professed interest in facts you still provide not a single fact supporting your spurious allegations that this site has been hijacked and only posted to by malcontents.

I suspect your interest in facts are only in those that support a belief that you already have (ie: surgery and nothing else), and that in fact you are immune to both reason and progress.

In regards to my email address that you derided ( and once again cowardly not providing one of your own), this is a real email address. I do not even know what my ISP email address is. I have switched ISPs many different times, yet my email address (due to sites like hotmail, yahoo, and google) has remained constant.

Proclaiming that I am hiding in the shadows while hiding behind the id No Name is another example of hypocrisy and cowardice.

Unfortunately you are the latest in a string of surgical proponents who while espousing facts and documentation never seem to provide any.

I tend to suspect that you are the latest incarnation of the individual who began posting as Gary and then morphed into Sean.

02/20/2005 23:12
No Name

not registered

02/20/2005 23:12
No Name

not registered

Randy and Tom

Boys:

You're both a couple of nut jobs. Wow! What anger! Who are you mad at and why? I'll stick to my statements that this website has been hijacked by the likes of you who enjoy attacking others. And, lose the hi-handed morality. My login has been used by others and that has been a common complaint and that is a fact.

Randy: provide a fact that surgeons don't know about NA. I'm just a average Joe with average insurance and I was able to learn about all the options before treatment. What boggles the mind is that this is a somewhat rare diesease and instead of supporting each other, its a war zone. Lighten up.

Until the site is a site for sharing information withou the insults, its a unless place.

02/20/2005 23:14
Me

not registered

02/20/2005 23:14
Me

not registered

Newbie

Dear No name,

Read deeper into the forum, there are many posts from people who's surgeons had not heard of NA - mine was one.

Me

02/20/2005 23:09
Randy H.

not registered

02/20/2005 23:09
Randy H.

not registered

Newbie

Until you can back up *your* assertions, It doesn't look all that good when you claim that others cannot. Anger has nothing to do with it. I don't mind a good rational non-personal debate if you are willing to engage in one. So far you have yet to bring anything of substance to the table to refute the final conclusion of my points:

7) Inasmuch as noninvasive procedures are badly needed, and NA has proven to be safe and effective, and this particular Forum has been the *only* significant means of informing Dups sufferers of it's existence......the continued discussion of NA on this Forum must and will continue. (That is why I am here and will continue.)

Instead all you can bring is calling me an "angry" "nut job" and then claim that *you* are the voice of calm and reason?

I still respect your right to have and express your opinions. At present, however, they simply don't seem to make any sense.

02/20/2005 23:27
Me

not registered

02/20/2005 23:27
Me

not registered

Newbie

Dear No name,

You are new to the forum.

For those of us who have been around for a while, our aim has always been to share experiences and exchange information about lastest treatments for DC.

Sometimes it is the message of NA, and sometimes it is not. You see descriptions of Lecithin, injex, various drugs, herbs, collegenase, physiotherapy, frozen shoulder, physiotherapists, comments by passing doctors, swimming excersises, the bowen technique, Pubmed, google Dr Bing a researcher, NICE and much more. This site is not just about NA, it is about exchange of ideas.

Over the past year there was a heated exchange regarding credentials between Frances and an individual who used many-many nicknames to make it appear that she was arguing with more then one person. But...she prevailed...she let him hang himself by pointing out that almost all the posts were written in a similar style and often with the same words. In fact, she ferreted out his manipulations with such success that he started using *her* nickname out of frustration, and that is when all this nonsense began. We keep hoping that it will end soon - but alas, he has posted again today.

No name, read more of the forum, you will see that toM and Randy are reasonable people.

Have a great night.



02/21/2005 23:35
Randy H.

not registered

02/21/2005 23:35
Randy H.

not registered

Scam Artists

Dear Me, (That sounds a bit schizoid :)

If my presence here can be legitimately criticized it would be, in fact, be for a near single minded enthusiasm for NA. This is probably because my Left is not doing so well 22 months post OP (most fair *far* *far* better with Open Surgery than I did). Due to this site I now have a shot at saving my dominant Right with a visit to Eaton in about 6 week from now. I see no problem in making my admitted *bias* and *agenda* perfectly clear to all.

Thanks for vouching for me if only for the sake of legitimizing the case for NA in the eyes of those who need to hear it.

RBH

02/25/2005 23:18
JERRY 
02/25/2005 23:18
JERRY 
Scam Artists

No need for me to interject since tOM and Randy are doing such great jobs in controlling our perpetual nemesis.

Glad you capable guys are aboard.

 1 2 3 4 5 6
 1 2 3 4 5 6
Interesting   debating   information   experience   Straightforward   Dupuytren~sq~s   surgery   physiotherapists   straight   individual   characteristic   everyone   accomplished   fingers   sharing   surgeons   treatment   because   procedure   address