| Lost password
59 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
Needle Aponevrotomy experiences
 1 .. 6 7 8 9 10 .. 20 .. 29
 1 .. 6 7 8 9 10 .. 20 .. 29
12/02/2002 23:00
Gary Evans

not registered

12/02/2002 23:00
Gary Evans

not registered

NA and surgery

John,
Thank you for your comments. I am not opposed to NA as I have said many times. I am for getting as much information out in this forum as possible. I think it is good to ask questions on procedures and information even if controversial. I do think it is worthwhile for the questions and answers to be somewhat thoughtful. Where is all of the anger coming from many of those who support NA as the only choice?

The big problem is the diathesis of each individual. Some procedures work for some people and some don't. It sometimes doesn't matter which procedure is used, it won't work out well. That is just the way DC is. Little fingers have a particularly high recurrence, no matter what procedure is used. Some people will have a very high recurrence depending on age, heredity and other factors or combination of factors. Most often, a person will only have one surgery and that will be their last. Of course there are many (including yourself) who will need another procedure. Same happens with many heart problems, hip replacement, knee replacement etc.

It is not of value to argue for one procedure or another. It should be good to be able to discuss the merits and detractions of the different procedures. I am not trying to "shout down" the NA supporters. If you notice, they are attacking every comment that anyone makes of any surgery for DC. Remember that worldwide it is by far the most common and accepted procedure, so why ignore it. Hopefully, with more research the solutions to DC will not make surgery necessary.

Gary
Gary

    12/02/2002 23:11
    TOm

    not registered

    12/02/2002 23:11
    TOm

    not registered

    NA

    Gary, prehaps you've been terribly terribly misunderstood.

    Since you're really into asking questions, why not question a medical establishment that will not perform NA in the US?

    Seems like your only serious questioning is to challenge endlessly any alternative treatment or treatments not performed in the US. I've never once read where you have questioned the limited options available in the US, other than to repeatedly imply that since they don't do NA in the US, must be something sinister or wrong with it.

    I'll agree, as I'm sure most will, that not all options work in all cases. However, the crime against those afflicted with DC, is that there are seriously limited options available in this country. That is why there is such a sense of outrage. One which you seem blissfully ignorant of understanding.

    That is why so many have become frustrated, angry with you, and felt you to be somebodies shill.

      12/02/2002 23:02
      Gary Evans

      not registered

      12/02/2002 23:02
      Gary Evans

      not registered

      NA

      You've got to be kidding. Do you think that I have the power to change the medical institutions of the world? There are very few countries who have accepted NA as a viable procedure for NA. It is not just the U.S., so your constant attacks on the AMA, the U.S. medical industry and specifically surgeons are not very productive. I certainly don't represent these people.

      Good luck with your ideas.
      Gary

        12/03/2002 23:34
        Tom 
        12/03/2002 23:34
        Tom 
        Let~sq~s tone it down!

        Nope, the only hope I have is that others afflicted with our malady seek out & question all options instead of being swayed by your narrow minded opinions and one sided rants.

        I honestly hope you have no influence with anybody whatsoever.

          12/03/2002 23:38
          Getting tired of ~dq~Tom & Jerry~dq~ stories

          not registered

          12/03/2002 23:38
          Getting tired of ~dq~Tom & Jerry~dq~ stories

          not registered

          Let~sq~s tone it down!

          Tom , you surely won't influence anybody, because you don't say anything !

            12/05/2002 23:02
            Mike

            not registered

            12/05/2002 23:02
            Mike

            not registered

            Let~sq~s tone it down!

            Tom, Jerry, Gary and others,

            I appreciate the advice and opinions that you very knowledgeable people contribute to the forum, but your animosity towards one another is counterproductive. Please maintain some professionalism and courtesy when addressing this forum...you are not the only ones that read it. Otherwise, we may one day wake-up and find this forum shutdown due to the proliferation of rude exchanges. That would not be fair to those of us who use it responsibly and rely on it for information. So, cut it out! Express your opinions with some civility and keep your egos in check!

            Mike

              12/05/2002 23:46
              miriam 
              12/05/2002 23:46
              miriam 
              medicare reimbursements

              Yesterday I went to an orthopaedist to get a new set of orthodics to accomodate the "lump" under both feet we all know is also dupuytrens but which they call plantar fibroma.
              I have dupuytrens on both hands and now on both feet.
              Doctor said he would take an impression of my feet and give me orthodics but that these WERE NOT COVERED by Medicare and that I needed to pay upfront. Amount was $450.00.
              When I told him I could not afford this he told me that I could make partial paymenets (as if this would change anything!). Of course Medicare WOULD
              pay should I get pain in the feet that prevents me from walking on them!
              Has anyone had any luck with Medicare and reimbursements even partially for these appliances?
              Thanks for your input.

                12/06/2002 23:23
                Tony 
                12/06/2002 23:23
                Tony 
                na

                Jerry,
                Thanks for the information. Very useful.
                Best regards, Tony

                  01/03/2003 23:11
                  cyndi

                  not registered

                  01/03/2003 23:11
                  cyndi

                  not registered

                  na

                  hi kristen,
                  if you don't mind would you please give an update on how your hand is doing now? i am looking into going to paris to have this procedure done.
                  thank you for taking the time to respond,
                  cyndi

                    01/03/2003 23:37
                    Mike K

                    not registered

                    01/03/2003 23:37
                    Mike K

                    not registered

                    Needle Aponevrotomy


                    Hi Cyndi,
                    I’m not Kristen, but if you will go to the following links, you can see the difference between the initial condition of the little finger on my right hand before NA, and in the second link, a picture taken one month after NA performed by Dr. Rappaport in Nov 02:

                    Before: http://www.mindspring.com/~mkempf/Main%20droite.jpg

                    After: http://www.mindspring.com/~mkempf/Main%20droite-Ensuite1.jpg
                    and: http://www.mindspring.com/~mkempf/Main%20droite-Ensuite2.jpg

                       1 .. 6 7 8 9 10 .. 20 .. 29
                       1 .. 6 7 8 9 10 .. 20 .. 29
                      Disease   procedure   recurrence   surgeons   surgery   Aponevrotomy   Question   medical   surgeon   treatment   fingers   results   fasciotomy   patients   procedures   Dupuytren   performed   information   experience   problem