| Lost password
94 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
NA doctors and radiation
 1 2
 1 2
11/12/2009 08:25
Steve G.

not registered

11/12/2009 08:25
Steve G.

not registered

NA doctors and radiation

Does anyone know what the opinion of radiation is for the leading NA doctors such as Dr. Eaton or Dr. Denkler or Dr. Kline? If they don't recommend, does anyone know why?

Steve G.

11/12/2009 14:37
flojo 
11/12/2009 14:37
flojo 
Re: NA doctors and radiation

When I was first in contact with Dr. Denkler, I was trying to determine if I needed NA or RT. I asked him and he left it up to me, but he made contact with a radiologist at UCSF who agreed to do it. He was not opposed to RT. They are just separate procedures anyway and RT will not do what NA does.
Ultimately, I had NA done first by Dr. Denkler and RT later by Dr. T at Scripps Clinic, La Jolla. Dr. T said that NA should be done first to release contracture because RT won't do that. RT is to stop progression, not fix contracture already in place. Fortunately for me, it did reduce the many nodules I had, reduced the tightness across my palm and increased the span from thumb to pinkie.

11/12/2009 14:44
wach 

Administrator

11/12/2009 14:44
wach 

Administrator

Re: NA doctors and radiation

flojo, your RT seemed to treat other nodules not the released cord. That sure makes sense to me. Radiating just a cord would have sound strange because RT doesn't do much on cords.

Wolfgang

11/12/2009 15:05
flojo 
11/12/2009 15:05
flojo 
Re: NA doctors and radiation

Yes, Wolfgang, that's what I think happened - shrinking nodules = less tightness. I think by radiating the nodules, that will keep cords from developing. I hope so. The cords I already had were not affected by RT at all that I could tell. They had already been released by NA. It makes sense to me that RT stopped the cords from progressing, because they were active and continuing to contract. I was fortunate to have mostly nodules.

11/12/2009 15:29
LubaM. 
11/12/2009 15:29
LubaM. 
Re: NA doctors and radiation

flojo....how long after you finished RT before you saw some results? ....

I am now in La Jolla getting treated by Dr. T. at Scripps and I have had 3 out of 10 treatments. The area he is radiating involves most of my left palm and a small cord that runs along my index finger. (I know radiation cannot help for cords...but he included this area because it has a nodule at the base of that finger)....

Like you, I plan to have Dr. Denkler release my pinkie on my other hand with NA and follow it up with radiation by Dr. T....how soon after the NA did you do the radiation?

11/12/2009 20:17
flojo 
11/12/2009 20:17
flojo 
Re: NA doctors and radiation

I noticed that the itchiness was not happening after the first week. The improvement was gradual. Dr. T had said that it would continue to improve for a month. Actually, it continued to gradually improve for 6-8 weeks. It wasn't immediate but I noticed that the nodules were smaller/flatter and with less tightness. I didn't have a splint, but I stretched it frequently during the day. At night, I'd flatten my hand out, palm down and stick it under my pillow or under my husband's shoulder. I don't know exactly when, but the tightness mostly went away. I didn't count the nodules or mark where they were, but I don't have as many and the ones left are smaller and just there, not bothering me.

I had RT almost 3 months after NA. I'd say having it a month after NA would be good. That gives the hand time to heal after NA. It may also depend on how severe the contracture is. Ask Dr. T. He may be the one who said one month after NA.

Good luck with your RT. I hope it is going to stop your Dups. Please keep us posted on how it goes and updates for the next few months.

11/12/2009 20:32
flojo 
11/12/2009 20:32
flojo 
Re: NA doctors and radiation

LubaM,

Do you live in SoCal? I live about 80 miles N. of San Diego in Riverside County.

You may be able to access my information and send me an email even if you are not registered on this site.

11/13/2009 00:17
newman 
11/13/2009 00:17
newman 

Re: NA doctors and radiation

Australia Callling, Just for information I had RT some 2 months after a repeat surgery. Keloids are eradiated within 24 hours after surgery.

11/13/2009 01:39
LubaM. 
11/13/2009 01:39
LubaM. 
Re: NA doctors and radiation

Interesting....Dr. T. told me that whenever I re-do NA on my right pinkie, I should come to him for RT of the right hand "the day after NA"....he feels the sooner after NA, the better.

By the way, Flojo...., I live in the L.A. area about 120 miles north of Scripps in La Jolla (almost 2-1/2 hrs. with traffic on 5) where I am now doing RT for my left hand...so we are staying in a hotel nearby for the two weeks of the treatment, because its too hard for us to drive 5 hours everyday.

So when I'm ready to do my right pinkie, I'll have to coordinate all these trips...drive from L.A. to Larkspur to do NA with Dr. Denkler, then return to L.A. and come to La Jolla for RT treatment, and rent a hotel again. (I did find a great hotel, Clarion Del Mar Inn, that has a special rate for Scripps patients).

I'm happy to hear that RT has helped you, flojo, and continued to improve after treatment ended...hope its the same for me. I couldn't find your email information,....but I'll continue to post results here.... thanks for all that you posted.

11/18/2009 01:53
moondanc 
11/18/2009 01:53
moondanc 
Re: NA doctors and radiation

Luba:

I had radiation on my right hand about 2.5 months after NA-- I had very few symptoms

I had radiation on my left hand 1 week after NA-- my radiation oncologist, Dr. Chang also thought it would be a good idea to have it as soon as possible after NA. This time I had ferocious itching and slight burning that started about a week after the treatment. It took 7-9 days to subside and my doc-- although he hasn't seen it--suspects I might have had a mild radiation reaction. Interestingly enough, it was mostly in the areas that are "sunken"-- not totally released by NA.

I'm curious whether those of you have had radiation therapy had a bolus used. "Bolus, a flabby, rubbery material, is used to 'fool' the radiation beam so it will deposit the maximum dose on the skin surface instead of a fraction of an inch deeper, as it would otherwise. Therefore, a skin reaction is almost inevitable in this scenario. Bolus is usually incorporated into radiation therapy when a surgical scar, such as a mastectomy scar, needs to receive a full dose of radiation therapy."

 1 2
 1 2
Interestingly   tightness   Interesting   treatment   contracture   Radiating   radiation   doctors   information   progression   improvement   Fortunately   nodules   it--suspects   Scripps   incorporated   progressing   Denkler   radiologist   because