| Lost password
212 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
UK treatment OR go abroad ?
 1
 1
11/21/2012 16:07
Jeremysadler 
11/21/2012 16:07
Jeremysadler 
UK treatment OR go abroad ?

As a completely new user of the forum and site I may be missing information that is available but which I cannot find. I know I have DC in my right hand which i can flatten by lkeaning my body weight on it (hurts though) and it is just beginning in my left hand. GP says I must wait until I am virtually disabled and the have surgery. So after using google etc etc to research I have noted that many UK patients state they "went to France" or "went to Paris". I have also now downloaded the list of clinics in the UK performing NA(PNF). Would it be feasible to ask anyone who has had either NA or xiapex treatments in UK ; How they accessed it and if it was private where they went and what it cost ; Also in same vein someone who had treatment in France exactly the same questions ; PLEASE ; I knwo I am late to the site but I keep reading that Mr or Mrs x had very succesful treatment by NA but nobody says ; It was Dr xxxx in Paris and it cost £xxxx

Please help ;

11/21/2012 16:49
spanishbuddha 

Administrator

11/21/2012 16:49
spanishbuddha 

Administrator

Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

NA is approved by NICE in the UK on the NHS, and there are quite a few clinics with hand surgeons who provide this treatment.

Xiaflex is approved by several NHS regions and so is similarly available.

Your GP is out of date and you should ask for a second opinion or referral to hand specialist/consultant either in your area, and who provides these treatments, or in one of the other areas listed on the British Dupuytren's website. http://dupuytrens-society.org.uk/TLinks.html

The BDS also has Facebook page where you could ask and reveal your location in the UK so others within that area can help if available.

To answer the question asked directly, I had RT in Germany at an approximate cost of £2000 including the travel and lodging. RT is also available privately in the UK, and in a few hospitals via the NHS.

Edited 11/21/12 18:53

11/21/2012 18:32
callie 
11/21/2012 18:32
callie 
Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

You said, "GP says I must wait until I am virtually disabled and the have surgery".

Go to a different GP. If you accurately stated what s/he said, that is very poor advice. S/he obviously has little knowledge about Dupuytren's and it would make one wonder about his/her knowledge about other medical conditions.

11/22/2012 09:42
Jeremysadler 
11/22/2012 09:42
Jeremysadler 
Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

Thanks for taking the time guys ; I already knew GP was not much help because he still thinks it only happens to alcoholics; I will attempt to re-visit and force a referral to a clinic that provides NA in UK ;

Anyone recommend a clinic in Northern France / Paris areas if this approach fails ?

11/22/2012 10:48
spanishbuddha 

Administrator

11/22/2012 10:48
spanishbuddha 

Administrator

Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

Doctors Badois, Manet, Lermusiaux and LeLouche on this list http://f.badois-dupuytren.assoc.pagespro...tml/gblist.html have been recommended in the past on this forum. I think Badois may have retired?

The LARIBOISIERE hospital, is conveniently located at the other end of Eurostar and will be where I will probably go if needed. http://www.dupuytren-online.info/NA_training_literature.html

However, Mr Chris Bainbridge has some responsibility for this UK training video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynSIchgNgdI so he may be able to advise within the UK. (He posted recently on this forum with a survey).

11/26/2012 18:05
Chrisbainbridge 
11/26/2012 18:05
Chrisbainbridge 
Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

Hi, the NHS says that you can have treatment when you fail the table top test or if you have any contracture of the PIP Joint.

So if you cannot put your hand flat on the table, you are eligible for treatment.

There are many units now doing NA in the UK in addition to our one here in Derby.

Xiapex is a fully licensed drug and we now have full approval from our clinical commissioning group so can offer Xiapex on the NHS to anybody, anywhere in the UK.

Many Primary care trusts/clinical commissioning groups do not want you travelling, but you have the absolute right to have your treatment anywhere in the country so just ask for the referral. They will suggest going locally first which is good. If you can get Xiapex or NA locally that has to be the best treatment. If you can't get what you want then ask for a second opinion!

I have heard from some patients that they have been told, that their Dupuytrens cannot be treated with Xiapex or NA. This is highly unlikely.

Chris

11/26/2012 20:31
Seph 
11/26/2012 20:31
Seph 

Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

Chris; I have had NA procedures from dr Badois in the past and last Friday Dr Manet. She is very good. Knows what she is doing. Injections hurt a bit more than with dr Badois but then my hand was in a worse state.

Important issue though for anyone in the UK - The cost is 250 euros. Less than the cost of a meal at a good restaurant in the UK.

Eurostar or ezijet to paris. Treatment takes 20-30 minutes. In short you could fly to Paris in the morning, have the NA procedure in the morning, have lunch in Paris and be back in the UK by the end of the day at a total cost less than 500 euros.

And you get to see someone who has done thousands of procedures rather than someone who is starting out.

I live in Australia and my health insurer won't pay for procedures overseas. They are happy to pay $10k for surgery but won't pay $250k for NA yet it still makes economic sense for me to have a week in Paris every 18months or so and have NA there. For you guys in the UK it seems to me like an easy call.

11/27/2012 03:03
potter 
11/27/2012 03:03
potter 
Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

Hi All,

The problem is that while Xiapex and NA and even RT have been approved by NICE, the local NHS PCTs - or at least the ones in southern England - haven't taken any of them on board yet. So we're still stuck in the same old post code lottery....

Chris, can you really offer either Xiapex or NA to me on the NHS? Surrey's guidelines have effectively stopped referral of all patients for these treatments citing a lack of documented long-term results and cost as the reasons... currently they offer only surgery as a 'cure'.

I've managed to get my insurance company to cover the first Xiapex treatment, but I'm left wondering how many further treatments they'll pay for before deciding it's a chronic disease and therefore not covered!

Be gentle, it's only my second post!

potter

11/27/2012 06:14
Chrisbainbridge 
11/27/2012 06:14
Chrisbainbridge 
Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

I would like to reassure the users of this forum that there is nobody doing NA in the UK who is a beginner. They are all fully trained hand surgeons, so they have done several hundred open dupuytrens operations giving them an unmatched insight into the anatomy of the hand, the pathology of Dupuytrens disease and the normal functioning of the hand. Believe me when you have had to put back together a few full house palm lacerations with tendons, vessels and nerves damaged you know the anatomy in ways no other specialty can.

Surgeons are by nature conservative, they generally do not jump on every "new thing" as so often it turns bad. We have seen that recently with PIP implants and some hip replacements. So if your surgeon doesn't do NA, he/she is simply doing the sensible thing of giving you a treatment that has withstood the test of time for the last 100 years.

Don't forget that Xiapex is an extremely dangerous drug. The collagenase is the same enzyme that let's flesh eating bugs be flesh eating! You can now see why your surgeon might be reticent about injecting you!

Having said that there are a few surgeons in the UK who are doing NA and Xiapex. I know of at least three centres who are offering these on the NHS. In Derby we are fully commissioned to offer both. They are not straight alternatives. NA is probably best for narrower primary cords and slightly older people due to the higher recurrence rate. Xiapex is great for patients with thick cords, younger age and rapid recurrence after NA. If you are needing NA after 12-18 months to the same finger you should really think about Xiapex. There are even some people who get rapid recurrence after Xiapex. The answer for them is a dermofasciectomy early when it is a good operation or possibly radiotherapy.

We routinely see patients from all over England and my hospital management simply send a bill to your PCT.

11/27/2012 17:16
Jeremysadler 
11/27/2012 17:16
Jeremysadler 
Re: UK treatment OR go abroad ?

Hi all ; As it was I that began the trail I thought I would give you an update ; Potter ; has exactly my problem and obviously lives in Surrey : Yes we`ve all got 4X4`s which obviously means we do not need the NHS ??? And yes we have ongoing issues getting NHS treatment (for anything) in the "well off" south. (just me being bitter)

BUT ; I can pay for treatment locally and get NA / PNF done for a current quoted cost of £750 Inclusive for 2 fingers. I suppose if you compare Rail travel costs in France to the UK the differential between the cost is approximately the same. Obviously my current situation a la Potter is; move out of South of England, Pay more locally or Pay less for the treatment and waste the savings on a weekend in France.

Allex les Bleu !

Many thanks to all for your comments though VERY helpful.

 1
 1
treatments   dupuytren-online   dermofasciectomy   responsibility   procedures   dupuytrens-society   treatment   recurrence   commissioned   radiotherapy   conservative   Dupuytrens   patients   badois-dupuytren   approximately   commissioning   available   differential   alternatives   v=ynSIchgNgdI