| Lost password
437 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
Dr. Weil Comments on D' on his site
 1
 1
04/09/2007 13:55
hellohello 
04/09/2007 13:55
hellohello 
Dr. Weil Comments on D' on his site

Hi all,

Dr. Andrew Weil just posted his comments on Dupytren's on his website at-
http://www.drweil.com/drw/u/id/QAA400181

Please let me know what you all think of the Potaba idea??

John M

04/09/2007 21:20
Randy_H 
04/09/2007 21:20
Randy_H 

Dr. Weil is misinformed on NA

DR WEIL:

"....the only available treatment to improve hand function is <Open> surgery"

While he does mention a "needle treatment" he then states that "the problem is likely to recur". Then he mentions partial (or Limited) fasciectomy and says "Dupuytren's can recur afterward but usually not as severely". What he doesn't apparently know is that Dr. Charles Eaton who has performed more NA *and* Limited fasciectomy that anyone on earth insists that NA will be sufficient for over 50% of new cases, so most people never need to undergo full Open Surgery.

John, my post has nothing to do with Potaba, but I can't let published misinformation remain uncorrected.

04/09/2007 22:26
hellohello 
04/09/2007 22:26
hellohello 
Re: Dr. Weil Comments on D' on his site

Randy H.,

Thanks for the clarification!

I don't personally know Dr. Weil, but knowing of him I think that he would be open to hearing this clarification also, if you feel so moved to send it.

How much does Dr. Eaton charge for an NA?

I am still interested in what people think of the Potaba idea?

John M.

04/10/2007 01:06
Mark_D 
04/10/2007 01:06
Mark_D 
Re: Dr. Weil Comments on D' on his site

John:

I have the highest respect for Dr. Weil.

In fact, I've read all of his books, except the Cook Book.

But, I must agree with Randy that Dr. Weil has missed the boat here by not talking about N.A.

I'm also interested in Dr. Weil's suggestion about Potaba. I've never heard about Potaba, & I wonder why it's a prescription drug if its a B-complex vitamin.

Mark

04/10/2007 08:13
Wolfgang

not registered

04/10/2007 08:13
Wolfgang

not registered

Re: Dr. Weil Comments on D' on his site

There are several comments about Potaba in this forum. The easiest way to locate them is to click on "search" (just below "Forum for Dupuytren e.V."), and then search for Potaba with the option "search in topics and answers" activated.

Wolfgang

Quote:


... I'm also interested in Dr. Weil's suggestion about Potaba. I've never heard about Potaba, & I wonder why it's a prescription drug if its a B-complex vitamin.

Mark


04/10/2007 16:09
jim_h 
04/10/2007 16:09
jim_h 
Re: Dr. Weil Comments on D' on his site

Potaba has been tried countless times over a period of decades, for Dupuytren's and Peyronie's. The overwhelming consensus of doctors and patients who have actually tried it is that it does not work. Nevertheless, it still continues to be mentioned as a treatment option.

04/10/2007 23:11
Mark_D 
04/10/2007 23:11
Mark_D 
Re: Dr. Weil Comments on D' on his site

Jim:

Thanks.

Mark

 1
 1
overwhelming   prescription   suggestion   B-complex   misinformed   interested   QAA400181   misinformation   fasciectomy   Dupuytren   Comments   uncorrected   apparently   Nevertheless   personally   performed   sufficient   published   clarification   treatment