| Lost password
37 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
Saw Dr. Eaton July 2nd
 1 2 3 4 5 .. 7
 1 2 3 4 5 .. 7
08/03/2004 23:50
Frances

not registered

08/03/2004 23:50
Frances

not registered

Old post

Hi Steve,

I don't remember which year it was posted, but I know it was years ago when I first found this forum...and to add to the aggravation...I am quite sure old messages have begun to scroll off....so you might not find it at all. Perhaps starting a new threat with a really claryifying subject line might shake people out of the trees.

Good luck, and let us know how your appt goes with Dr. Eaton.

Frances

08/03/2004 23:02
Randy H.

not registered

08/03/2004 23:02
Randy H.

not registered

Bye

Sean,

Like I said earlier when Eaton turned out to be for real and doing a great job with NA in the US:

Thanks for Playing....IT'S OVER!

08/03/2004 23:14
Linda 
08/03/2004 23:14
Linda 
ANOTHER SUCCESSFULL

SEAN.. YOU ARE A RIOT!! How could you possible with good conscious..suggest traditional surgery to any one..All they have to do is go to Dr. Eaton's site www.handcenter.org and look at some of the traditional surgery pictures...It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure it out...N.A. all the way........Traditional surgery butchers your hands..and you know it............GO SELL VACUMM CLEANERS.....

08/03/2004 23:58
Sean 
08/03/2004 23:58
Sean 
Surgery

Believe it or not, but Dr. Eaton is still performing surgery for Dupuytren's. Why would I need to look at the pictures when I watched my surgery? Some of you act as though it (Dupuytren's) is major surgery. Good luck when you have a hip replacement.

Why do you have a problem with people having successful surgery for Dupuytren's? It is interesting that all of you decide to write at the same time. Perhaps all the same person, or you were all waiting together for my once in two months posting.

08/03/2004 23:11
Sean 
08/03/2004 23:11
Sean 
NA

" How could you possible with good conscious..suggest traditional surgery to any one.."

Linda,
Why wouldn't I suggest it, along with NA? My surgery couldn't have been better. It has been almost three years since surgery and my hand is as good now as it was previous to Dupuytren's. My hand was at 85 degrees and now at 0 degrees with no visible scar. Why is that a problem for you? Why is that a problem for anyone? That doesn't mean that I might not have NA on my other hand when the time comes, but it would be difficult to experience as good of results as I had with surgery.

08/03/2004 23:09
jim h

not registered

08/03/2004 23:09
jim h

not registered

thoughts on surgery

I haven't checked this forum in a long time and good grief, this argument about surgery never ends. For the record: I've had surgery on each hand and I'd grade the results as B+ in one case and C and in the other.

The surgeries were a bit creepy, it's true. And recovery was long and tedious. But, my hands certainly weren't "butchered", and the contractures haven't returned (almost 6 years in one case). The worst problem is with a PIP joint - as predicted, it froze up in the year following the surgery. For the most part I regained full movement.

Next time, like everyone, I'll give Dr. Eaton the first call. But I think there are probably still cases that require surgery.

08/03/2004 23:13
honest abe

not registered

08/03/2004 23:13
honest abe

not registered

thoughts on surgery

While there are probably quite a few bad surgeries and we hear from many of those people still searching for solutions on this website, the many people who have success in traditional surgery (except for sean) have probably moved on with their lives and you wouldn't even know they had dupuytrens disease since they don't have bent fingers anymore. If I had a good procedure and wasn't looking for answers I wouldn't be here (unless there was a reason to champion an alternative like NA if that is what worked for me and I felt I owed it to others to pass the word on). Think about it. Does the newspaper ever report about the girl who got an A and went to Harvard or the dropout who was on drugs...

08/04/2004 23:53
Kristen 
08/04/2004 23:53
Kristen 
Contracture return after NA

This is in response to Steve's earlier posting in this thread about his contracture returning very quickly after NA. I am curious - is it in the pinky? I also have a VERY aggressive case of DC. I have had NA 6 times in the past 4 years on my right ring finger and 4 times on my left pinky. The last 2 times the pinky relapsed in only 6 weeks, so I no longer get NA performed on it - the PIP joint is totally frozen at this point anyway. I discussed the problem with Dr. Eaton and his recommendation is to perform surgery on just the pinky, not the palm, and to fuse the PIP joint at a more manageable 45 degree angle - it's now a bit past 90 degrees. He has told me that the PIP joint will NEVER work again. I am considering this - unfortunately, I have Blue Cross insurance and Dr. Eaton is not a provider, so I will need to fund this with lottery winnings or a bank robbery.

08/04/2004 23:49
steve 
08/04/2004 23:49
steve 
reply

No, my contracture is not just the pinky. It is a palmar cord near the base of the right ring finger that is pulling down that finge and both the pinky and middle finger. Luckily, I have only MP contractures at this point which are less involved. It does sound like you and I are having similar problems. Did you go to france for your earlier NA procedures before seeing dr. eaton? Has he tried colchicine with you yet to slow the progress? I just a prescription for that so I'll see how it goes.

08/04/2004 23:33
Kristen Metzger

not registered

08/04/2004 23:33
Kristen Metzger

not registered

Response to Steve

Steve - Yes,I've been getting NA in France for years, from Drs. Badois, Lellouche and Lermusiaux. Dr. Lermusiaux gave me colchicine in March, which I took for 3 months and it had no effect. I went to Dr. Eaton last month for the first time. Dr. Eaton gave me a prescription for Allopurinol 3 weeks ago, so it's a little early to judge if it will help. Dr. Eaton is only 40 miles from me or I would have continued with the French doctors. Also, I knew that I needed to find a surgeon to deal with the out of control pinky problem, Dr. Eaton did much more extensive work in my palm than the French doctors and I'm hoping that the results will be more long lasting. (one would hope so - My last visit to Dr. Lermusiaux was $60 (20 min.) - Dr, Eaton was $1200 (over an hour)- fortunately I'm not prone to fainting or heart problems!) Good luck. Kristen

 1 2 3 4 5 .. 7
 1 2 3 4 5 .. 7
degrees   surgery   surgeon   disease   bio-mechanically   contracture   because   understandable   recurrance   colchicine   completely   another   contractures   procedure   acetyl-l-carnitine   aggressive   aggressiveness   problem   dupuytren   traditional