| Lost password
137 users onlineYou are not loggend in.  Login
Anyone have any success with an alternative treatment?
 1 2 3
 1 2 3
04/04/2006 23:27
Tommy

not registered

04/04/2006 23:27
Tommy

not registered

NA in UK

Marjorie,

Unless I'm reading it incorrectly, there's a 2-16-06 post under the topic "UK NHS Acceptance of NA" from Michael that says he had NA in the palmar region from a doctor in Chester.

04/04/2006 23:33
Nick

not registered

04/04/2006 23:33
Nick

not registered

Alternatives to Surgery

Thanks for your advice Marjorie. I will certainly look into NA possibilities further. While, from what I read, it is not necessarily the "no brainer" suggested by Tolucca below, it looks a much better option and less invasive than surgery. I guess what we all really long for is some better understanding of the condition and a more long term solution. Hence my interest in other alternatives as well as NA.

I looked back to some of the earlier posts on acupuncture and the discussion seemed to quickly polarise between advocates who'd had some success and critics who believed it was acupuncturists touting for business. I am somewhere in the middle. I have no special interests to push and am generally quite sceptical about many alternative therapies (especially when they come with psychobabble), but my conclusion about my acupuncture treatment is that it probably had some beneficial effect in stopping DC progress but without any miracle reversing effect. Therefore, I don't think we should dismiss it and only pin our hopes on NA, which seems to be the case in much of what I've read in this forum. So I'd be very interested to hear of anyone else with good or bad experience of other alternatives...

Nick

Nick

04/04/2006 23:23
marjorie 
04/04/2006 23:23
marjorie 
NA in Chester

Dear Tommy,
Thanks for pointing that post out to me. I was out of the country from 8th Feb for 1 month.
Now, I am not normally a sceptic but, having had NA with Dr Lermusiaux and driven him mad with questions, I am aware that the cord needs cutting from the palm to the first finger joint so that the finger can straighten, as the cord is wrapped around nerves and tendons and the finger will not straighten unless several breaks are achieved. It is easy to do NA in the palm without risk of damaging a nerve but not easy on the finger itself. I would not trust anyone who had not had the proper training. The comment about a local surgeon being involved is not something I am aware of. The only time this is necessary is when there is a tendon rupture, the chance of this happening is miniscule.
My information about no NA in the UK came from the BSSH, there is certainly no-one registered. I will admit that there may be some hand surgeons who do as the one in Chester does but there is no-one who is Paris trained.
I know who I will trust my precious hands to.
Marjorie

04/04/2006 23:59
Tolucca

not registered

04/04/2006 23:59
Tolucca

not registered

The Current Alternative to OS

Nick,

As yet, nothing has been shown to effectively stop this disease. Nothing. And, at this time there are only three corrective interventions in existence: Open Surgery, NA, and Collagenase injections. If you are considering a medical intervention, only OS and NA are currently available.

They are as different as night and day. And yes, it is in fact a No Brainier to try NA before engaging in major surgery of the hand. While this is certainly matter of opinion, it is the opinion shared universally by all who have experienced it. Other than rare cases of unacceptable rates of recurrence, I have yet to see or hear of a single negative patient report concerning NA. There is good reason why those of us who have actually had NA are so enthusiastic.

I realize the lack of similar enthusiasm on the part of the medial establishment must be taken into account by those considering their options. Because of that it's really only the doctors who perform NA, and the patients who have had it, that really know what they are talking about. I'm sure that sounds very cut and dry, but there is really no other way to say it.

 1 2 3
 1 2 3
aggressive   treatment   procedure   dupuytren-onine   stretching   Dupuytren~sq~s   interventions   recommended   patients   interphalangeal   contracture   physiotherapist   acupuncture   alternatives   dupuytren`s   therapy   conservative   surgery   July-discharged   acupuncturists